‘Love Island USA’s Kaylor Martin Confirms Aaron Evans Split Before Reunion—But Fans Are Skeptical

Would you like Swooon in your inbox? Signup for our Swooon! newsletter!

Are they or aren’t they? Well, if you take Kaylor Martin’s word for it, she and and Aaron Evans are over. Kaylor was interviewed outside of the Love Island USA reunion special and spilled the tea.

“Aaron and I are not okay,” Kaylor can be heard saying in the TikTok video. “We are done. We are not together.” After that, it’s unclear what Kaylor said about Aaron.

@slaaasherr kaylor and aaron are DONE omg #loveisland #kaylor #aaron #breakup #nyc #reunion #tea #leah ♬ original sound – asheroliver

Despite Kaylor’s words, fans aren’t so sure that she’s done with Aaron for good. “But the lock screen is crazy Kaylor,” a fan commented, referring to Kaylor’s phone lock screen being a photo of her and Aaron on Love Island USA. Another user added, “Yall she has Aaron and herself as her wallpaper please I’m not falling for this lmaoo.”

Over on X, a fan had a theory about Kaylor and Aaron’s post-breakup future. “Kaylor and Aaron broken up which means they’re both gonna be cast on love island games 2 and then get back together,” the fan wrote.

Kaylor and Aaron had one of the most tumultuous relationships in the villa during Season 6. In a post-elimination interview, Kaylor admitted that her “perspective” on Aaron changed after she was able to watch what went down between Aaron and Daniela Ortiz Rivera at Casa Amor. “Like the stomach kisses in the morning and the breakfast and then also I saw Aaron break things off with Daniela and then…lean in for a kiss, and all of those things have changed my perspective,” she said on the BFFs podcast.

She also said she wanted to “take a step back” with Aaron in light of what she learned.  “I don’t wanna end things, because I know what Aaron and I had was true and real, but I feel like I just gave him chance after chance … and it wasn’t even all of the Casa [Amor] thing, it was just more so him not taking accountability like Kordell [Beckham] did, which really hurt,” Kaylor continued.

The on-again, off-again couple were dumped ahead of the finale. Serena Page and Kordell Beckham won Season 6. The cast, including Kaylor and Aaron, will be getting together to discuss everything that went down in the villa during the Love Island USA Season 6 reunion special. Should be spicy!

Love Island USA Season 6 Reunion, August 19, 9/8c, Peacock