‘Only Murders in the Building’: Who Killed Sazz Pataki? Every Important Clue So Far

[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers for Only Murders in the Building Season 4, Episodes 1-6.]

Only Murders in the Building is back for Season 4 and with it the mystery of Sazz Pataki’s (Jane Lynch) death. Charles’ (Steve Martin) stuntwoman from Brazzos seemingly didn’t make it out of his apartment alive as the premiere episode’s final moments uncovered her remains in The Arconia’s incinerator. But how did she get there?

Below, we’re breaking down all the clues so far and will continue to do so as Season 4 unfolds on Hulu each week. Stay tuned for updates as Charles, Mabel (Selena Gomez), and Oliver (Martin Short) tap into their latest case.

Sazz Gone Missing

Hulu

When Charles returns to his apartment with Oliver and Mabel on the official opening night of Death Rattle, Sazz’s body is nowhere to be found, despite fans seeing her lying on Charles’ kitchen floor at the end of Season 3. Without the initial knowledge of harm to Sazz, the trio carries on not understanding that a crime has been committed there. When Charles reaches out to Sazz, he receives brief responses from her phone, but when the trio heads out west to Los Angeles, he’s met with mail at Sazz’s door, suggesting no one has been around to pick it up.

Eager to find his friend, Charles believes he spots Sazz at a party for the movie that’s being made about the Only Murders podcast, only to discover it’s Scott Bakula, who like Charles, hasn’t seen or heard from Sazz. This raises major alarm bells.

Sazz’s Own Clues

Hulu

When Charles convinces Oliver and Mabel to visit Sazz’s apartment with him, they find a bevy of clues scattered across her desk. The only problem? It’s a bunch of gibberish to the trio who have a tough time deciphering their meaning. Among some of the notable teases is a paper that has “West Tower Arconia,” written on it, as well as papers that have number codes, and the words “Long Game” and “Dudenoff” on them. What could they mean? Only time will tell.

Howard’s Cadaver Dog Gravey

Hulu

Howard’s (Michael Cyril Creighton) new dog, Gravey, was vital in cracking the initial case as Mabel learned the pup was a cadaver dog, explaining the pet’s freakout when visiting Charles’ apartment. Taking this information back to New York, Mabel, Charles, and Oliver seek out Howard’s help in sniffing out Sazz’s remains, found in The Arconia’s incinerator.

As for stepping outside of the cat-guy label by adopting a dog, Creighton tells TV Insider, “I think it’s great. I think that his passion for animals is just growing and growing. I just thought he was a cat guy, but I’m so delighted to find out. He’s also a dog [guy].” Could Howard’s dog get more involved with the case? Stay tuned to find out.

The Bullet Hole

Hulu

Following Sazz’s death, Charles hears whistling in his apartment and learns after the fact that it’s being caused by a bullet hole in his window, serving as evidence of Sazz’s murder. When doorman Lester (Teddy Coluca) calls Charles while away in Los Angeles, he notes that he’s working on having the window replaced after receiving a note requesting such, but Charles realizes someone is trying to cover up the evidence and asks Lester to refrain from changing anything. Could analysis of the bullet hole help point Charles, Mabel, and Oliver in the direction of Sazz’s killer?

The Gun

Further investigation revealed that the weapon that created the bullet hole in Charles’ window was a hunting gun, meaning that the killer was using a weapon that required some experience. Initially, Rudy (Kumail Nanjiani) was considered a potential suspect when Mabel and Eva Longoria noticed a weapon on his mantle, but it was quickly uncovered as a dud.

The Westies

Disney/Patrick Harbron

Situated across the way from Charles’ apartment, the Westies are the tenants in the Arconia’s west building. Their apartments face Charles’ window and despite learning that their big scheme is to maintain subletting rent-controlled apartments, we’re not entirely sure they’re off the suspects’ list. In fact, they’ve never seemed guiltier of possible murder than they have as of now. But why?

Dudenoff

Related

How Oliver and Loretta Became ‘Only Murders in the Building’s Best Love Story

That would be because of Dudenoff (Griffin Dunne), the professor who had supposedly purchased all of the apartments on the floor where the suspicious Westies live, and whose own apartment was seemingly vacant turned up dead among the ashes recovered alongside Sazz’s. So, who is really at fault for their deaths? Most signs are pointing to the Westies who had a lot to gain by keeping Dudenoff and anyone else who could ruin their scheme out of the picture.

But what do you think? Weigh in on the comments section, below, and stay tuned as the mystery continues to unfold.

Only Murders in the Building, Season 4, Tuesdays, Hulu