Is Wrigley Actually in Love With Bree on ‘Tell Me Lies’? Our Theory

Tell Me Lies Season 2 came to an end on October 16 with a jaw-dropping finale. From Drew’s (Benjamin Wadsworth) fate to Stephen (Jackson White) and Lucy’s (Grace Van Patten) wedding hookup to Stephen sending Evan’s (Branden Cook) confession to Bree (Cat Missal), the second season of the Hulu drama series didn’t hold back. Since I binged the screeners weeks ago, I’ve been stewing on this theory: Wrigley (Spencer House) is in love with Bree in the 2015 timeline.

I could be dead wrong about this. I probably am. But there’s a chance I could be right. There have been many incredible fan theories about Tell Me Lies Season 2, which has allowed my theory to run rampant in my mind. Wrigley and Bree only started manifesting in my brain when I started thinking about Season 3. (Hulu has not announced a renewal as of this post’s publication.)