‘The Challenge’s Beth Insists ‘I’m Not a Liar’ After Jonna Cheating Rumor: Inside Her Allegations

Beth Stolarczyk and Jonna Mannion‘s beef started on Season 3 of The Challenge: All Stars in 2022, and now they’re forced to work together on Season 5, which has a Rivals theme. The drama runs deep with the women, though, since it was more than just cutthroat gameplay that led to the tension between them.

Even though Stolarczyk was only on Season 3 for two episodes before her exit, there was plenty of time for her to perpetuate a shocking rumor about Mannion. The two wound up facing off in an elimination, with Stolarczyk quitting before they completed it.