‘Dirty John’: The TV Characters vs. Their Real-Life Counterparts (PHOTOS)
Connie Britton as Debra Newell
As a successful businesswoman looking for love, she’s the perfect target for John’s purposes. Despite her family’s aversion, she can’t see anything beyond John’s kind exterior and false personality.
Debra Newell
As a target of one of John Meehan’s many cons, Debra Newell didn’t heed the initial warnings from her family about his shady story. Marrying shortly after meeting, Debra’s connection with Meehan eventually grew volatile when she tried to divorce him.
Eric Bana as John Meehan
Portraying an ultimate con-man, Bana’s acting skills are on full display as he plays John’s con-side against the real him.
John Meehan
An expert con-man, John Meehan deceived Debra Newell and nearly everyone in his life. Eventually his lying catches up to him though as [Spoiler] Meehan died after and altercation with Debra’s daughter Terra.
Julia Garner as Terra Newell
Playing Debra’s youngest daughter, Julia Garner plays up Terra’s suspicions to match the real-life version. Ultimately the story will come to a shocking conclusion when Terra gets into a scuffle with John.
Terra Newell
The youngest daughter of Debra, Terra played an integral part in John Meehan’s story — [Spoiler] she killed him in self defense when he showed up outside of her apartment wielding a knife.
Jean Smart as Arlane Hart
Smart portrays Debra’s mother Arlane in a shocking transformation. The actress is nearly unrecognizable with her snow-white do and granny glasses.
Arlane Hart
Hart is the real-life mother of John’s last con victim Debra, and like much of the family, had her suspicions about John.
Sprague Grayden as Tonia Bales
As the ex-wife of John, her relationship to the con-man will come into play with his and Debra’s story during the show.
Tonia Bales
As John’s first wife, Tonia endured more than a decade of marriage with the con-man, sharing two daughters with him in the process. Prior to their divorce she wasn’t aware of Meehan’s behavior.
True-crime stories have captured audiences for years, and the recent Bravo series Dirty John is exactly the brand fans are willing to buy.
What happens when you take a con-man, mix him together with a business woman, and sprinkle in some suspicious family members? You get this new limited series that was inspired by the true story of John Meehan and Debra Newell. Their saga became a podcast, which eventually turned into the TV show, but throughout that time most of the actual people involved with the case of John Meehan weren’t afraid of showing themselves.
Because of their willingness to talk about the story, we are able to compare the casting of Dirty John to the real-life individuals involved.
Above, we’ve collected images to see how spot-on the show was in creating this true-crime drama. (Note: Some of the photo captions contain spoilers to the story.)
Dirty John, Sundays, 10/9c, Bravo
Watchlist Easy access to only the shows you care about — all in one simple place
Alerts Only important notifications — when a show is returning, when it becomes available to stream, and more.
Special Offers Exclusive products we release related to your favorite shows and streaming services